Paul and Debbie Caforio are a fun-loving couple that enjoys traveling, serving, and spending time with their children and grandchildren. From their years of worldly travel they have learned the importance of customer service, hospitality and small, meaningful details. This unique insight and their personal work ethic keeps them committed to providing all guests with a 5* experience for every visit. With four spectacular properties to offer, we are certain that you will find your new favorite vacation spot. We rent all year long! Sunset Paradise and Sunset Oasis are next door to each other while Sunset Haven is 300ft down the road and Sunset Retreat is a short three mile drive down the same road. Inviting friends and booking multiple for an extra special and spacious get together with friends and family is encouraged!

Adorable cottage on private road right on Cayuga Lake. 5 minute drive to Aurora and a 35 minute drive to Ithaca/Auburn. Beautiful lake views and amazing sunsets make for a relaxing getaway! The cottage has one bedroom in the main house and a bonus bunkhouse a few steps from the front door with multiple beds. Play cornhole in the beautiful yard or sit by the fire pit and watch the waves. Beautiful hot tub views after a day in the lake or in the brisk mornings. Dock and deck that gives enough room for the family to dine outside! There is a dishwasher, washer and dryer. Come make Cayuga Cottage your home away from home. A note regarding location: Sunset Retreat is located approximately 3 miles from the start of a private, single lane road. It takes approx. 15 mins to arrive at Sunset Retreat if you drive the 10mph speed limit (which we greatly encourage you to do 🙂). You are driving lakeside the entire time past beautiful home after beautiful home, so while this could seem like an extra distance or inconvenience we choose to take it as an opportunity to slow down and “enjoy the views” that beautiful Cayuga Lake and the quiet private road have to offer. The road is well maintained through all seasons and easily drivable in any weather. Additionally, owners Paul and Debbie live less than 20 minutes away so if you encounter any accessibility issues they are close by and fully committed to assisting as needed. There is a grocery store in Union Springs, Auburn and Ithaca. There are a couple local convenience stores around Aurora.

Cayuga Lake is beautiful and the wineries are unmatched! There are five wineries within a 5-10 mile radius of the cottage and ample eateries as well.